My 8 Month Test With Watch Gang

A 12 Month Review of (Black Tier)

Author: Gerrund Pacia
Date: Wednesday, February 14th, 2017

Eight months ago, none of my friends would have called me a watch enthusiast or even a collector. That has changed a bit. 8 months ago I didn't know much about watches and I certainly didn't have a passion for them. My wife bought me two memberships to Watch Gang for my birthday. Why two? Because they had a $29 and $99 membership and she didn't know which one I'd like more. I'd heard of Watch Gang and I had even watched some of their giveaway videos but sort of chalked it up as a gimmick.

So what is Watch Gang? For $29 or $99, Watch Gang ships you a new mystery watch that you keep that is supposed to be worth more than you pay. It works a lot like other "____ of the month" clubs where you pay a membership fee and get products worth more than your fee because they can buy in bulk. Watch Gang is doing things a bit differently, though. They don't send everyone the same watch and as a membership bonus, they do a live Rolex and TAG giveaway every week. So to be clear, I am not renting the watch and I don't have to send it back. It's mine to sell or smash with a hammer - whatever I want.

I documented my experience each month and compared it to Watch Gang's guarantee. For $29 they promise a watch worth $50-$150. For the $99 membership, they promise a watch worth $150-$500. Obviously I love that my wife got this for me but I also thought that I'd probably not like most of the watches I am sent. Worst case, I figured I'd learn about watches and give them out as gifts if they didn't fit my style. I am documenting the watches I received, some details about it and the price I found it for online (along with any notes about my experience in that month). If you want to skip the details and just read the 8 month summary, click here. So here we go:

February 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Breed Alpha 2

This was my first watch from Watch Gang. I like the style just fine and I can definitely find times to wear it. It's sort of a sporty style. I was impressed that I received a Swiss watch in my $29 membership.

THE VALUE - $149 (5x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Air Blue Charlie World Time

I actually love this watch and it gets weekly wrist time. It's a military inspired pilot watch and it's truly beautiful. The value is solid. I'd never heard of Air Blue before so it's pretty cool that I got a watch I like so much that I never would have found without Watch Gang.

THE VALUE - $293 (3x membership value)

March 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Deportes Stainless Steel Mesh

Honestly, not a big fan of this one. I don't really love mesh bands. I gifted this watch to my brother and he loved it. I'm happy that it was worth 3x what I paid.

THE VALUE - $99.99 (3x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Boldr "Panda" Chronograph

Another homerun in the Watch Gang $99 membership. Aside from the design (which I LOVE), the value is amazing. $518 to buy this watch online. It uses a movement often found in TAG watches.

THE VALUE - $518 (5x membership value)

April 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Bernoulli Banshee

Not bad at all. I like the green on the bezel and the swirled dial is pretty cool. I might wear this a few times and then try to trade it. Again, the value is pretty good - 3x my cost.

THE VALUE - $99.99 (3x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Citizen Eco Drive Titanium

I've actually owned a couple Citizen watches so I am well aware of the brand. This is a very light weight watch because the case is made completely out of titanium. It's an eco-drive which means it's powered by light. Mine has a black ostrich leather strap. Value is pretty good at 2.5x what I paid.

THE VALUE - $243.75 (2.5x membership value)

May 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - 32 Degrees Swiss Diver

VERY impressed with this one at the $29 level! This is a Swiss watch that will most certainly get a lot of wrist time. The lume on it is excellent; it glows very bright at night and underwater.

THE VALUE - $99.99 (3x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Egard Navita

I'd say this is the most unique watch I've received so far. I'm not sure how I feel about it. It has very good quality and I'm not complaining too much at receiving an almost $1,000 watch ($375 on sale) for my $99. I also like that this is an automatic watch which means it doesn't use a battery and winds itself as I wear it.

THE VALUE - $375 (3.75x membership value)

June 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Jet Set New York

I don't love gold, but I do actually like this watch. It goes with a few outfits and the whole reason for the club is to get a good value and discover watches I wouldn't have known about before. I think for those reasons, this is a solid watch. Great value at almost 6x what I paid.

THE VALUE - $173.37 (6x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Heritor Odysseus

I look at this watch in pictures and have to say it is strikingly more beautiful in person. This is my first skeleton watch (and another automatic) and it's a great dress watch for me to wear. Again, 6x value.

THE VALUE - $600 (6x membership value)

July 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Simplify 2800

I think it's pretty cool that this came with an extra band and a tool. I was able to swap the strap myself and I now basically have 2 watches for the price of one. And a tool to use on my other watches. I enjoy that I'm learning more about watches and how they work.

THE VALUE - $250 (8x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Tschuy-Vogt Centurion Swiss Chronograph

Don't get me started on the name. I don't know how to say it, but I do really like this one. It's another Swiss watch and it's heavy! The links in the band are solid and this feels like a very expensive piece.

THE VALUE - $199 (2x membership value)

August 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - PureDial Square Legacy

Well... a square watch with a purple dial. Surprisingly I do actually wear this watch! It is a nice dress watch. I only wear it with a suit. The purple is very cool! It has what is called a "sunburst" dial and when the light hits it, wow! Thanks to Watch Gang for getting me to step out of my comfort zone! Even if I hated this, at $29 I'll just give it to a friend. Glad I like it though!

THE VALUE - $125 (4x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - TW Steel Canteen

The TW Steel I received has a very nice blue dial with gold accents. It's a bit big for me, so I sold this on eBay for $205. Actually made a profit on my membership by doing that.

THE VALUE - $274.69 (2.7x membership value)

September 2017

--- $29 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Pulsar Classic Solar Powered

Pulsar is owned by Seiko which is one of the biggest watch companies in the world. I was surprised that Watch Gang was able to nail them down as a partner. No complaints at all about this one. I like it a lot and I wear it often!

THE VALUE - $78.37 (2.7x membership value)

--- $99 Membership ---

THE WATCH - Armand Basi "Pepsi Dial" Rocket

This is what I'm talking about! The colors, the automatic movement, the travel case, the extra strap - it's amazing! What a win! And worth $450!

THE VALUE - $450 (4.5x membership value)

8 Month Summary

Watches received: 16
Total cost of membership so far: $1,040
Total value of membership so far: $4,029.15
= 4x Membership Value on Average

I have to hand it to the folks at I received this membership as a gift but was skeptical. Out of the 16 watches I received, I only hated 1 of them. I was on the fence about 4 others but I was able to gift them or sell them really easily. By April (month 3), I was itching to get my shipment! This feels like an addiction. They ship on the 16th of each month. It really feels like my birthday every month. What a gift! I've learned about watches and have drastically stepped up my wardrobe. I am going to keep my subscription going and I'll post another update at the 1 year mark!


I am 100% behind this company. They have an amazing community of watch lovers and they truly care about their members. I'm getting nice, expensive watches for a super low membership fee.

Go to and sign up!


IMPORTANT: You must sign up today and use promo code WATCHMESHIP to get your watch shipped free!

Get Your First Watch Now!

Sign up with this link and get your first watch shipped for free! Just use the promo code WATCHMESHIP on the checkout page and it will make shipping absolutely free!


Terms | Privacy Policy